Uncategorized
Jordan Katz 2018 Big Board: Top 50
This is my own personal big board for the 2018 NFL Draft. The players may not represent the order that I have them in on my most recent mock draft. This is strictly my rankings of each players and how they will translate as pros. This year I put the grade I gave them along with their rankings.
To be clear, this is a vague big board for now. I will add my number evaluations to my final big board so you all can see a more in depth breakdown of where I value each player.
For this one in particular, a first round grade for me means that I believe they are an NFL starter. It’s hard to predict who will be a NFL superstar because so much of their success is dependent upon which team they are selected to. Generally speaking, if someone gives a player a first round grade, it means they think that player can start at the next level for an extended period of time. A second round grade for me means that they can be a starter down the road, but there are some questions at the moment. The 1st/2nd hybrids are guys that can be starters from day one, but also have some issues in their game.
1) Saquon Barkley, RB Penn State (1st Round Grade)
2) Quenton Nelson, OG Notre Dame (1st Round Grade)
3) Roquan Smith, ILB Goergia (1st Round Grade)
4) Bradley Chubb, DE NC State (1st Round Grade)
5) Vita Vea, NT Washington (1st Round Grade)
6) Minkah Fitzpatrick, CB/FS/SS Alabama (1st Round Grade)
7) Baker Mayfield, QB Oklahoma (1st Round Grade)
8) Josh Rosen, QB UCLA (1st Round Grade)
9) Sam Darnold, QB USC (1st Round Grade)
10) Derrius Guice, RB LSU (1st Round Grade)
11) Braden Smith, OT/OG Auburn (1st Round Grade)
12) Tremaine Edmunds, EDGE/OLB Virginia Tech (1st Round Grade)
13) Connor Williams, OT Texas (1st Round Grade)
14) Carlton Davis, CB Auburn (1st Round Grade)
15) Derwin James, FS/SS Florida State (1st Round Grade)
16) Denzel Ward, CB Ohio State (1st Round Grade)
17) Arden Key, EDGE LSU (1st Round Grade)
18) Billy Price, OG/OC Ohio State (1st Round Grade)
19) Da’Ron Payne, DT Alabama (1st Round Grade)
20) Will Hernandez, OG UTEP (1st Round Grade)
21) Jaire Alexander, CB Louisville (1st Round Grade)
22) Sony Michel, RB Georgia (1st Round Grade)
23) Joshua Jackson, CB Iowa (1st Round Grade)
24) Ogbonnio Okoronkwo, OLB Oklahoma (1st/2nd)
25) Marcus Davenport, EDGE UTSA (1st/2nd)
26) Isaiah Oliver, CB Colorado (1st/2nd)
27) Ronald Jones II, RB USC (1st/2nd)
28) Orlando Brown, OT Oklahoma (1st/2nd)
29) Anthony Miller, WR Memphis (1st/2nd)
30) Leighton Vander Esch, ILB Boise State (1st/2nd)
31) Mike McGlinchey, OT Notre Dame (1st/2nd)
32) Taven Bryan, DT Florida (2nd Round Grade)
33) DeShon Elliott, FS Texas (2nd Round Grade)
34) Harrison Phillips, DL Stanford (2nd Round Grade)
35) Isaiah Wynn, OG Georgia (2nd Round Grade)
36) Dante Pettis, WR Washington (2nd Round Grade)
37) Christian Kirk, WR Texas A&M (2nd Round Grade)
38) Dallas Goedart, TE South Dakota State (2nd Round Grade)
39) Kerryon Johnson, RB Auburn (2nd Round Grade)
40) Sam Hubbard, EDGE Ohio State (2nd Round Grade)
41) Holton Hill, CB Texas (2nd Round Grade)
42) Derrick Nnadi, DT/NT Florida State (2nd Round Grade)
43) Mike Hughes, CB South Florida (2nd Round Grade)
44) Chukwuma Okorafor, OT Western Michigan (2nd Round Grade)
45) Martinas Rankin, OT Mississippi State (2nd Round Grade)
46) Terrell Edmunds, SS Virginia Tech (2nd Round Grade)
47) Rashaan Evans, ILB Alabama (2nd Round Grade)
48) Mark Andrews, TE Oklahoma (2nd Round Grade)
49) Michael Gallup, WR Colorado State (2nd Round Grade)
50) Alex Cappa, OT/OG Humboldt State (2nd Round Grade)
Jordan Katz 2018 Top Five By Position
This is my own personal list for my top five players by position. These rankings may not reflect the order that I have them in my recent mock draft. My mock draft is based on team needs as well as scheme fits.
Quarterbacks:
1) Baker Mayfield, Oklahoma
2) Josh Rosen, UCLA
3) Sam Darnold, USC
4) Josh Allen, Wyoming
5) Lamar Jackson, Louisville
Running Backs:
1) Saquon Barkley, Penn State
2) Derrius Guice, LSU
3) Sony Michel, Georgia
4) Ronald Jones II, USC
5) Kerryon Johnson, Auburn
Wide Receivers:
1) Anthony Miller, Memphis
2) Dante Pettis, Washington
3) Christian Kirk, Texas A&M
4) Michael Gallup, Colorado State
5) Calvin Ridley, Alabama
Tight Ends:
1) Dallas Goedert, South Dakota State
2) Mark Andrews, Oklahoma
3) Mike Gesicki, Penn State
4) Troy Fumagali, Wisconsin
5) Hayden Hurst, South Carolina
Offensive Tackles:
1) Connor Williams, Texas
2) Orlando Brown, Oklahoma
3) Mike McGlinchey, Notre Dame
4) Chukwuma Okorafor, Western Michigan
5) Martinas Rankin, Mississippi State
Interior Line:
1) Quenton Nelson, Notre Dame
2) Braden Smith, Auburn
3) Billy Price, Ohio State
4) Will Hernandez, UTEP
5) Frank Ragnow, Arkansas
EDGE Rushers:
1) Bradley Chubb, NC State
2) Arden Key, LSU
3) Marcus Davenport, UTSA
4) Hercules Mata’Afa, Washington State
5) Dorance Armstrong, Kansas
Interior Defensive Lineman:
1) Vita Vea, Washington (Nose Tackle)
2) Da’Ron Payne, Alabama
3) Taven Bryan, Florida
4) Harrison Phillips, Stanford
5) Derrick Nnadi, Florida State
Non-Edge Linebackers:
1) Roquan Smith, Georgia (ILB)
2) Tremaine Edmunds, Virginia Tech (OLB)
3) Ogbonnia Okoronkwo, Oklahoma (OLB)
4) Leighton Vander Esch, Boise State (ILB)
5) Tegray Scales, Indiana (OLB/ILB)
Cornerbacks:
1) Carlton Davis, Auburn
2) Denzel Ward, Ohio State
3) Jaire Alexander, Louisville
4) Josh Jackson, Iowa
5) Isaiah Oliver, Colorado
Safeties:
1) Minkah Fitzpatrick, Alabama
2) Derwin James, Florida State
3) DeShon Elliott, Texas
4) Ronnie Harrison, Alabama
5) Terrell Edmunds, Virginia Tech
Jordan Katz: 2017 Big Board (Top 75)
1- Myles Garrett, EDGE Texas A&M
2- Reuben Foster, ILB Alabama
3- Jamal Adams, FS/SS LSU
4- Solomon Thomas, DE Stanford
5- Marshon Lattimore, CB Ohio State
6- Taco Charlton, DE Michigan
7- Ryan Ramczyk, OT Wisconsin
8- Malik Hooker, FS Ohio State
9- Leonard Fournette, RB LSU
10- Jonathan Allen, DE/DT Alabama
11- Corey Davis, WR Western Michigan
12- Sidney Jones, CB Washington (Injured)
13- Forrest Lamp, OG Western Kentucky
14- Jake Butt, TE Michigan (Injured)
15- OJ Howard, TE Alabama
16- Adoree Jackson, CB/FS USC
17- Mitchell Trubisky, QB North Carolina
18- Zach Cunningham, OLB/ILB Vanderbilt
19- Budda Baker, CB/FS Washington
20- Montravius Adams, DT Auburn
21- Gareon Conley, CB Ohio State
22- Dalvin Cook, RB Florida State
23- Carl Lawson, EDGE Auburn
24- David Njoku, TE Miami Florida
25- TJ Watt, OLB Wisconsin
26- Tre’Davious White, CB LSU
27- Obi Melifonwu, FS/SS UCONN
28- Jarrad Davis, ILB/OLB Florida
29- Jabrill Peppers, FS/SS/LB/RB Michigan
30- Haason Reddick, ILB/OLB Temple
31- Alvin Kamara, RB Tennessee
32- Tarell Basham, DE Ohio
33- Evan Engram, TE Ole Miss
34- Christian McCaffrey, RB Stanford
35- Mike Williams, WR Clemson
36- Derek Barnett, EDGE Tennessee
37- Deshaun Watson, QB Clemson
38- Fabian Moreau, CB UCLA
39- Zay Jones, WR East Carolina
40- Derek Rivers, EDGE Youngstown State
41- D’Onta Foreman, RB Texas
42- Chris Godwin, WR Penn State
43- Rasul Douglas, CB West Virginia
44- Ahkello Witherspoon, CB Colorado
45- Jordan Willis, EDGE Kansas State
46- Jaleel Johnson, DT Iowa
47- Marlon Humphrey, CB Alabama
48- Damontae Kazee, CB San Diego State
49- Marcus Maye, FS Florida
50- Patrick Mahomes II, QB Texas Tech
51- Cam Robinson, OT Alabama
52- Jordan Leggett, TE Clemson
53- John Ross III, WR Washington
54- Chidobe Awuzie, CB/FS Colorado
55- Pat Elflein, OG/C Ohio State
56- Malik McDowell, DE/DT Michigan State
57- Tim Williams, EDGE Alabama
58- DeShone Kizer, QB Notre Dame
59- Amara Darboh, WR Michigan
60- Quincy Wilson, CB Florida
61- Chris Wormley, DT Michigan
62- Marcus Williams, FS Utah
63- Desmond King, CB/FS Iowa
64- Dan Feeney, OG Indiana
65- Charles Harris, EDGE Missouri
66- Elijah Qualls, NT Washington
67- Ryan Switzer, WR North Carolina
68- Dion Dawkins, OT/OG Temple
69- Ryan Anderson, OLB Alabama
70- Bucky Hodges, TE Virginia Tech
71- Daeshon Hall, EDGE Texas A&M
72- Chad Hansen, WR California
73- Garett Bolles, OT Utah
74- Taylor Moton, OT/OG Western Michigan
75- Alex Anzalone, OLB/ILB Florida
Jordan Katz 2017 Top 5 By Position
This is my own personal list for my top five players by position. For edge rushers, I put them at what I feel is their more natural position, be it a 4-3 defensive end or a 3-4 outside linebacker. This goes for offensive lineman as well. If I believe a tackle is better suited at a guard, I put him there. This also may not reflect the order that I have them in my recent mock draft. My mock draft is based on team needs as well as scheme fits.
Quarterbacks:
1) Mitch Trubisky, North Carolina
2) DeShone Kizer, Notre Dame
3) Deshaun Watson, Clemson
4) Patrick Mahomes, Texas Tech
5) Davis Webb, California
Running Backs:
1A) Leonard Fournette, LSU
1B) Dalvin Cook, Florida State
3) Christian McCaffrey, Stanford
4) D’Onta Foreman, Texas
5) Jeremy McNichols, Boise State
Wide Receivers:
1) Corey Davis, Western Michigan
2) Mike Williams, Clemson
3) Malachi Dupre, LSU
4) John Ross III, Washington
5) Cooper Kupp, Eastern Washington
Tight Ends:
1) Jake Butt, Michigan
2) David Njoku, Miami Florida
3) Jordan Leggett, Clemson
4) OJ Howard, Alabama
5) Gerald Everett, South Alabama
Offensive Tackles:
1) Ryan Ramczyk, Wisconsin
2) Mike McGlinchey, Notre Dame
3) Julie’n Davenport, Bucknell
4) Garrett Bolles, Utah
5) Cam Robinson, Alabama
Interior Line:
1) Quenton Nelson, Notre Dame
2) Pat Elflein, Ohio State
3) Forrest Lamp, Western Kentucky
4) Dan Feeney, Indiana
5) Mason Cole, Michigan
Defensive Ends:
1) Myles Garrett, Texas A&M
2) Jonathan Allen, Alabama (3-4)
3) Taco Charlton, Michigan
4) Malik McDowell, Michigan State (3-4)
5) Solomon Thomas, Stanford
Defensive Tackles:
1) Malik McDowell, Michigan State
2) Montravius Adams, Auburn
3) Vita Vea, Washington (Nose Tackle)
4) Caleb Brantley, Florida
5) Chris Wormley, Michigan
3-4 EDGE Rushers:
1) Myles Garrett, Texas A&M
2) Tim Williams, Alabama
3) Carl Lawson, Auburn
4) Derek Barnett, Tennessee
5) Harold Landry, Boston College
4-3 Outside Linebackers/Inside Linebackers:
1) Reuben Foster, Alabama (MLB)
2A) Zach Cunningham, Vanderbilt
2B) Jarrad Davis, Florida
2C) TJ Watt, Wisconsin
2D) Anthony Walker, Northwestern (MLB)
Cornerbacks:
1) Teez Tabor, Florida
2) Quincy Wilson, Florida
3) Sidney Jones, Washington
4) Marlon Humphrey, Alabama
5) Desmond King, Iowa
Safeties:
1) Jamal Adams, LSU
2A) Jabril Peppers, Michigan
2B) Malik Hooker, Ohio State
4) Marcus Maye, Florida
5) Justin Evans, Texas A&M
Jordan Katz NFL Mock Draft 3.0- Post Combine
The NFL Combine went a long way towards proving something that i have said throughout the draft process; this is a weak NFL Draft class. Having said that, there are still guys that have the talent to help turn losing franchises into winning ones.
In this mock draft I expanded to two rounds to give you more of a sense of my value of players and how they can fit with certain teams. Even though I question the star power of this draft, I do think that this draft has solid pros that can help teams.
1) Tennessee Titans- Laremy Tunsil, OT Ole Miss- The Titans have put this pick on the trade block (like we told you they would a month ago), but I doubt they get the deal they want. In a weak draft class, the Titans would have to take less value if they moved the pick. Because of this, there’s a good chance they just stay where they are and take Tunsil.
2) Cleveland Browns- Jared Goff, QB California- Goff is more NFL ready than Carson Wentz, which is why Cleveland should take him instead of Wentz. I’d offer more analysis, but I don’t believe a QB in this draft deserves a top 10 pick. This pick is strictly because the Browns are going to take a quarterback.
3) Atlanta Falcons via San Diego Chargers- Joey Bosa, DE Ohio State- In the last mock draft I had Atlanta move up to the fourth pick to land their star defensive player. After further review, the Chargers seem adamant about moving down in this draft. Acquiring multiple future assets makes the most sense for San Diego.
4) Dallas Cowboys- Myles Jack, OLB UCLA- I tried to have Dallas trade down, but there weren’t enough teams interested in paying the asking price of the fourth overall pick.
The Cowboys could use to bolster their defense if they stay at this spot (I don’t think the number four pick is where you take a backup QB). Jack is a phenomenal athlete with elite cover skills. He would be a great addition to the Cowboys front seven.
5) Jacksonville Jaguars- Jalen Ramsey, CB/S Florida State- Ramsey moved up to my top player in the draft after a phenomenal combine. The Jaguars desperate need of secondary help would make this an easy selection.
6) Baltimore Ravens- DeForest Buckner, DE Oregon- Buckner is an unbelievable athlete for a 3-4 defensive end. He’s quick off the ball, and has the tools to become one of the top 3-4 ends. In the Ravens defensive system, Buckner should flourish for many years.
7) San Francisco 49ers- Vernon Hargreaves, CB Florida- Hargreaves had a very solid day at the combine, and solidified himself as a top ten pick in this draft. His ball skills and press man ability will help him make an instant impact in the NFL.
8) Miami Dolphins- Kevin Dodd, DE Clemson- Dodd is one of my favorite players in this draft because of his versatility to play 4-3 or 3-4 defensive end. He has a good move set when rushing the passer, and he’s a complete run stopper. The Dolphins could use a defensive end of the future because Olivier Vernon and Cameron Wake are likely not on the team after this season.
9) Tampa Bay Buccaneers- Mackensie Alexander, CB Clemson- This is a reach pick, but the Buccaneers desperately need a cornerback. Alexander’s lack of ball skills has come into question (he didn’t have an interception in college), but that shouldn’t deter Tampa Bay from selecting a solid cover corner.
10) New York Giants- Shaq Lawson, DE Clemson- The Giants would have a field day with this pick because Lawson, Ronnie Stanley and Ezekiel Elliott are all on the board. I think the loss of JPP makes Lawson more of a priority for the Giants in this scenario.
11) Chicago Bears- Ronnie Stanley, OT Notre Dame- It is true that the Bears biggest need is to improve their defense, but they also need to protect Jay Cutler better. Stanley can be a starting left tackle from day one.
12) New Orleans Saints- Josh Doctson, WR TCU- Throughout my scouting process, I have had Josh Doctson incredibly close to Laquon Treadwell. After a terrific combine where he put his great ball skills on display, Doctson has surpassed Treadwell on my board.
13) Houston Texans via Philadelphia Eagles- Carson Wentz, QB North Dakota State- The Eagles continue to trade down, but this time it’s not with the Seahawks. The Texans jump up to grab their quarterback of the future, while the Eagles add some assets in preparation for a rebuilding process.
14) Oakland Raiders- Reggie Ragland, ILB Alabama- I think Oakland could consider Jaylon Smith here if his physical checks out in a few weeks. However, after showing that he was behind schedule at the combine, the Raiders choose Ragland instead.
15) St. Louis Rams- Laquon Treadwell, WR Ole Miss- Treadwell fell behind Doctson in my rankings because he chose not to run the 40 yard dash at the combine. The concern with Treadwell is that he doesn’t have breakaway speed. By not running, he didn’t do himself any favors.
Having said that, I still believe Treadwell is a very good NFL prospect. He’s got a big frame, and he knows how to use his body to help him get good position when the ball is in the air.
16) Detroit Lions- Sheldon Rankins, DT Louisville- Rankins was my big winner from the combine. He looked great during the on field drills, and his short shuttle indicates that he possesses the quickness and explosiveness that he showed on tape.
17) San Diego Chargers via Atlanta Falcons- Jason Spriggs, OT Indiana- The Chargers need to protect Philip Rivers much better in 2016, and Spriggs is the last tackle on my board that’s worth a first round pick.
If you’re wondering why they wouldn’t have taken Stanley at the third overall pick, it’s hard to pass up two future draft picks when this draft class is so weak.
18) Indianapolis Colts- Emmanuel Ogbah, EDGE Oklahoma State- I think Ogbah surpassed Spence by showing athleticism that proved he could win one-on-one battles. I know the Colts are being rumored to drafting a running back, but I think they have to go defense in round one.
19) Buffalo Bills- Noah Spence, EDGE Western Kentucky- Rex Ryan’s defense is predicated on getting to the passer. After cutting Mario Williams, Ryan will need to draft someone to play opposite Jerry Hughes.
Spence may not have ran a great 40 time, but he still shows good pass rushing skill on tape.
20) New York Jets- Ezekiel Elliott, RB Ohio State- I highly doubt ‘Zeke falls outside the top ten, but if the Giants pass on him, he could make it to the Jets at 20 because of team needs. General Manager Mike Maccagnan would be ecstatic if that happened.
21) Washington Redskins- A’Shawn Robinson, NT Alabama- Terrance Knighton wants to return to Washington, but he also wants a long-term deal. I don’t think he’ll get both, which means he will probably be playing elsewhere.
That means the Redskins need to replace him. Robinson’s athleticism will allow them to keep the same defensive system up front. They probably not lose a step of production either.
22) Philadelphia Eagles via Houston Texans- Cody Whitehair, OT/OG Kansas State- Whitehair’s athleticism reminds a lot of scouts of Zack Martin, which is why many think he will transition from guard to tackle at the next level. I think he’s a starting right guard from day one in a zone-blocking scheme.
23) Denver Broncos via Minnesota Vikings- Jaylon Smith, OLB/ILB Notre Dame- The Broncos can’t keep everyone on their all-pro defense, and one of the guys destined to leave is Danny Trevethan. Smith showed up at the combine a little behind schedule, but he’s a top five talent and definitely worth the Broncos taking a gamble by moving up for him.
24) Cincinnati Bengals- Corey Coleman, WR Baylor- The Bengals are being gutted at the wide receiver position via free agency. Coleman is the best of the bunch not named Doctson or Treadwell because of his explosiveness with the ball in his hands and route running ability.
25) Pittsburgh Steelers- Kenny Clark, NT UCLA- Clark is a great run stopper, which is a necessity for Pittsburgh’s defense heading into next season. It’s true that they also need secondary help, but I think they’ll try to address that in free agency.
26) Seattle Seahawks- Robert Nkemdiche, DT Ole Miss- Nkemdiche had some awful meetings with teams at the combine, which may cause him to fall out of the first round. However, I still see a top ten talent on tape. I think Seattle can afford taking a chance because of the culture Pete Carroll has created.
27) Green Bay Packers- Austin Johnson, DT/NT Penn State- Johnson’s measurables at the combine didn’t emulate the athleticism I saw on tape, but he put that on display during the drills. I still think he can be on of the top players in this draft.
28) Kansas City Chiefs- Taylor Decker, OT Ohio State- This is a bit of a reach, but the Chiefs are in desperate need of offensive tackles. Decker is solid enough to be a starting right tackle right away.
New England Patriots- (Forefeit)
29) Arizona Cardinals- Christian Hackenburg, QB Penn State- I thought Hackenburg showed excellent footwork during the drills at the combine. His accuracy needs to improve, but he has the skills to become something after sitting for a year.
Arizona needs to start grooming a young quarterback behind Carson Palmer. I think Hackenburg’s upside makes this a solid selection.
30) Carolina Panthers- Kamalei Correa, DE Boise State- Correa has great speed off the edge, but his move-set needs some fine tuning. The Panthers could use a true edge rusher to keep their defense at an elite level.
31) Minnesota Vikings via Denver Broncos- Joshua Garnett, OG Stanford- Garnett is a starting right guard from day one because of his ability to get leverage and run block. This is a very good fit for the Vikings because of how often they run the rock.
TRADES
1) Atlanta Falcons trade the #17, #50, a 2017 1st and a 2017 3rd to the San Diego Chargers for the #3 overall pick.
2) Houston Texans trade the #22 and the #52 to the Philadelphia Eagles for the #13.
3) Denver Broncos trade the #31 and the #95 to the Minnesota Vikings for the #23.
ROUND TWO
32) Cleveland Browns- Jonathan Bullard, DE Florida
33) Tennessee Titans- William Jackson III, CB Houston
34) Dallas Cowboys- Alex Collins, RB Arkansas
35) San Diego Chargers- Sterling Shepard, WR Oklahoma
36) Baltimore Ravens- KeiVarae Russell, CB Notre Dame
37) San Francisco 49ers- Andrew Billings, NT Baylor
38) Jacksonville Jaguars- Shilique Calhoun, EDGE Michigan State
39) Tampa Bay Buccaneers- Derrick Henry, RB Alabama
40) New York Giants- Will Fuller, WR Notre Dame
41) Chicago Bears- Jarran Reed, DE Alabama
42) Miami Dolphins- Su’a Cravens, LB/S USC
43) *Los Angeles Rams via Philadelphia Eagles- Will Redmond, CB Mississippi State
44) Oakland Raiders- Darian Thompson, FS Boise State
45) Los Angeles Rams- Connor Cook, QB Michigan State
46) Detroit Lions- Tyler Boyd, WR Pittsburgh
47) New Orleans Saints- Vernon Butler, DT/NT Louisiana Tech
48) Indianapolis Colts- Shon Coleman, OT Auburn
49) Buffalo Bills- Landon Turner, OG North Carolina
50) Atlanta Falcons- Darron Lee, OLB Ohio State
51) New York Jets- Sebastian Tretola, OG Arkansas
52) Philadelphia Eagles via Houston Texans- Jihad Ward, DE Illinois
53) Washington Redskins- CJ Prosise, RB Notre Dame
54) Minnesota Vikings- Michael Thomas, WR Ohio State
55) Cincinnati Bengals- Chris Jones, DT Mississippi State
56) Seattle Seahawks- Jack Conklin, OT Michigan State
57) Green Bay Packers- Shon Coleman, OT Auburn
58) Pittsburgh Steelers- Hunter Henry, TE Arkansas
59) Kansas City Chiefs- Artie Burns, CB Miami Florida
60) Chicago Bears via New England Patriots- Devontae Booker, RB Utah
61) Arizona Cardinals- Ryan Kelly, C Alabama
62) Carolina Panthers- Jeremy Cash, SS Duke
63) Denver Broncos- Christian Westerman, OG Arizona State
*- Eagles traded pick to Rams in Sam Bradford trade.
TRADES
1) Chicago Bears trade #71 and a 2017 3rd to the New England Patriots for the #60 and a 2017 5th.
Jordan Katz 2016 Big Board: Top 25
This is my current top 25 players as of my mock draft 2.0.
1) Joey Bosa, DE Ohio State- Bosa is a do-it-all defensive end that’s well deserving of the top pick. He’s an explosive pass rusher with a terrific move set.
2) Jalen Ramsey, CB/S Florida State- I think Ramsey projects better as a free safety, but he’s still worthy of a top five pick at corner. His versatility is what makes him my second overall player.
3) Ronnie Stanley, OT Notre Dame- Stanley and Tunsil are incredibly close, but I think Stanley is better suited to play left tackle in multiple systems, which gives him the slight edge.
4) Laremy Tunsil, OT Ole Miss- Tunsil’s athleticism for a tackle makes him an incredibly intriguing prospect. I think his upside might eclipse Stanley’s, but Stanley is a little more polished right now.
5) Kevin Dodd, DE Clemson– Kevin Dodd is one of my favorite players in this draft. He’s disruptive in the run game, and shows the ability to rush from multiple spots on the defensive line.
6) Laquon Treadwell, WR Ole Miss- Treadwell reminds me of AJ Green. He has great a terrific catch radius and he high points the ball very well. He’s also a very clean route runner for a bigger receiver.
7) Myles Jack, OLB UCLA- I’ve never scouted a player quite like Myles Jack. He’s an incredible athlete for a linebacker, but I expected him to make more plays on tape. Despite this, I still think he will be a stellar pro.
8) Shaq Lawson, DE Clemson- Lawson is a smart, instinctive pass rusher with a polished move set. That alone makes him a top ten pick this year.
9) Vernon Hargreaves, CB Florida- Some may complain that Hargreaves doesn’t have ideal size, but I don’t think that will prohibit him from succeeding in the NFL. He’s very good in man-to-man coverage and his technique allows him to be very good in press coverage.
10) Robert Nkemdiche, DT Ole Miss- I’m a little higher on Nkemdiche than most. I think he’s an elite pass rusher, and a terrific athlete. He will need a more consistent effort level in the NFL, but if he gets his act together, he could be a top three player in 2016.
11) Josh Doctson, WR TCU- In my opinion, Doctson is the most explosive offensive player in this draft. He high points the ball well, he has deep threat ability and he runs clean routes. He could fly up draft boards after the combine.
12) DeForest Buckner, DE Oregon- Buckner is a monster as a 3-4 defensive end. He’s got a great get-off and possesses elite athletic ability. It wouldn’t shock me if Buckner wound up being one of the top five players in this draft down the road.
13) Kenny Clark, NT UCLA- Clark is very reminiscent of Danny Shelton from last year. I think he’s a terrific space eater, but he doesn’t win one-on-one matchups a lot. Having said that, I still think Clark is a top 15 player because of his value in a 3-4 one gap system.
14) Jaylon Smith, LB Notre Dame- Before the ACL injury Smith was my third rated player in this draft. He’s the most complete linebacker I’ve scouted since CJ Mosley. If I owned a pick in the 15-25 range this year, I would sacrifice the first eight weeks of the season (he’s projected to miss the first half of the 2016 season) for the chance to have someone of his talent.
15) A’Shawn Robinson, DT/NT Alabama- Robinson is another defensive tackle that has incredible athletic ability for his size. He’s not as polished as Kenny Clark, but he should be a very productive pro.
16) Ezekiel Elliott, RB Ohio State- ‘Zeke isn’t quite Todd Gurley, but in a weak draft class he could be worth a top ten selection. He’s got the home run ability that all the great running backs have; anytime he touches it, he’s a threat to go all the way.
17) Mackensie Alexander, CB Clemson- Alexander reminds me of Jason Verrett. He’s strong in man coverage against an opposing team’s X, Y, or Z receiver. This will be his greatest asset come draft day.
18) Corey Coleman, WR Baylor- Coleman put on a route running clinic during the first two-thirds of the season until the Bears were decimated by injury. He’s explosive with the ball in his hands as well. The one concern is whether he’s a system product of Head Coach Art Briles.
19) Reggie Ragland, ILB Alabama- Speaking of system fits, I present another Alabama defensive product. I think Ragland’s sideline-to-sideline range is impressive, but it’s hard to know whether he’s not a product of another highly talented defense from Tuscaloosa.
20) Jared Goff, QB California- I’m not sold on any of the quarterbacks in this draft class, but the potential for Goff to be a game changer at the most important NFL position (shout out here, you know who you are) elevates him to the top 20. Goff can make all the throws, but needs to become more consistent to excel in the NFL.
21) Carson Wentz, QB North Dakota State- Wentz gets the same treatment as Goff, although I have more hope for Wentz. He’s an impressive athlete for someone who’s 6-foot-5 and he has a cannon for an arm. If he becomes more accurate, he could be a star.
22) Landon Turner, OG North Carolina- Turner may not be the best athlete, but I’m a sucker for interior lineman that can gain leverage at the point of attack with their power and pad level. He’s going to be a really strong run blocking right guard in the NFL.
23) Mackensie Alexander, CB Clemson- Alexander reminds me a lot of Jason Verrett. He’s a little undersized, but his man coverage ability allows him to guard receivers that are lined up out wide, or in the slot.
24) Jonathan Bullard, DE Florida- Bullard has the versatility to play both 4-3 and 3-4 defensive end. He gets good leverage at the point of attack and shows a terrific motor on tape.
25) Kevin Peterson, CB Oklahoma State- Peterson is my sleeper of the draft. His technique is beyond impressive, which allows him to stay with bigger and stronger receivers. A strong 40 time in Indianapolis may propel him into the middle of round one.
Jordan Katz: NFL Mock Draft 2.0-Post Super Bowl Mock Draft
The NFL offseason has officially begun, which means the Tennessee Titans are on the clock, more or less. Now it is true that the NFL Combine, and most major free agency moves, will occur before the Titans are actually on the clock.
However, that doesn’t mean that things haven’t changed since our last mock draft. Not only is the draft order finalized, but also Senior Bowl week had a major impact on many players’ draft stock.
Plenty of things will change in the coming months, but for now, this is the way I think the first round of the draft should go down.
ROUND ONE
1) Tennessee Titans- Ronnie Stanley, OT Notre Dame- I think the Titans will listen to trade offers leading up to the draft, but if they stay put, Stanley or Laremy Tunsil seem like the only viable options.
2) Cleveland Browns- Jared Goff, QB California- Even though I wouldn’t take any of the quarterbacks this high, the Browns are going to. Personally, I would trade down if I was in charge. I don’t believe their franchise quarterback is in this draft class. Even if he is, the Browns have so many needs that their quarterback might turn into David Carr due to a lack of pieces around him.
3) San Diego Chargers- Laremy Tunsil, OT Ole Miss- Eventually the Chargers will figure out that in order for Philip Rivers to be successful, he needs to be protected in the pocket. Hopefully it’s this draft, considering there are two talented tackles at the top of the board.
4) Atlanta Falcons via Dallas Cowboys- Joey Bosa, DE Ohio State- I think the Dallas Cowboys are in an ideal position to trade down. They can acquire future draft picks for a top five selection that they don’t need to use. This is how the good franchises stay good.
The Falcons will have to give multiple early selections to move up this high, but it might be worth it. Atlanta’s defense really struggled to get to the quarterback last season, mostly because they didn’t have anyone opposite Vic Beasley. Bosa is an unbelievable talent and he would make a major impact on Atlanta’s defense from day one.
5) Jacksonville Jaguars- Jalen Ramsey, CB/S Florida State- Unless a team trades up past the Jaguars to select Ramsey, then this is probably the easiest selection in 2016. The Jaguars need secondary in the worst way, and Ramsey is a star in the making.
6) Baltimore Ravens- Vernon Hargreaves, CB Florida- I think the Ravens are a sneaky “trade down,” candidate, but the versatility that Hargreaves brings to the cornerback position is too much for them to pass up on.
7) Detroit Lions via San Francisco 49ers- Laquon Treadwell, WR Ole Miss- The Niners have more than one big need, and the positions they need would be a reach here.
Fortunately for them, the Lions just lost Calvin Johnson, and must replace him with a number one receiver if they want to get back to where they were in 2014.
Treadwell would become Stafford’s favorite target in a hurry because of his ability to be physical and his ability to high point the football.
8) Miami Dolphins- Myles Jack, OLB UCLA- This is another pick that seems like a match made in heaven. Jack’s athletic ability would allow him to shine behind an underrated front four.
9) Tampa Bay Buccaneers- Kevin Dodd, DE Clemson- In my opnion, Dodd is the most complete defensive end in this draft class not named Joey Bosa. He seems like the pick for the Bucs, who are in desperate need of a true pass rushing threat.
10) New York Giants- Shaq Lawson, DE Clemson- The Clemson boys go back-to-back in this mock draft. Lawson might have a more complete move set than his counterpart, which makes him a hot commodity in the 2016 draft.
11) Chicago Bears- DeForest Buckner, DE Oregon- Bucker has moved up my personal big board since my last mock draft because of his athleticism and ability to gap the run.
However, he remains at 11 because the teams that need defensive ends at the top of the draft are 4-3 teams.
12) New Orleans Saints- Mackensie Alexander, CB Clemson- Despite solid play from Delvin Breaux last season, the Saints don’t have a true number two corner. Alexander has the versatility to play on the outside as well as in the slot, a skill that the Saints could desperately use.
13) Seattle Seahawks via Philadelphia Eagles- Robert Nkemdiche, DT Ole Miss- I still think this deal is a perfect match. The Eagles add extra draft picks; the Seahawks get a pass-rushing monster to replace Brandon Mebane.
14) Oakland Raiders-Reggie Ragland, ILB Alabama- It’s hard to know whether a Nick Saban defensive product is one that looks good, or one that is good. Ragland appears to be the latter based on his range and ability to read and react in coverage.
15) Los Angeles Rams- Josh Doctson, WR TCU- In the last mock draft I had the Rams jump up to ensure that they landed Doctson, who’s home run threat ability makes him a bona-fide number one receiver. In this mock draft, they don’t have to move up to get him.
16) San Francisco 49ers via Detroit Lions- Carson Wentz, QB North Dakota State- I know Wentz isn’t going to make it this far on draft day, and he might soon surpass Jared Goff on my personal board.
However, based on my evaluations, no quarterback in this class deserves to go in the top 15 (I excluded the Browns from this because they’re going to go quarterback at the second overall pick regardless of logic).
17) Dallas Cowboys via Atlanta Falcons- Ezekiel Elliott, RB Ohio State- One of the reasons that I think the Cowboys are a great candidate to trade down is because their top need is number one running back, which is not something you draft at four. Trading down allows them to pick up assets and select a game changing running back.
18) Indianapolis Colts- Kevin Peterson, CB Oklahoma State- Peterson is a technician at the cornerback position, which allows him to stay with receivers that are bigger than him. He may not be a first rounder in the eyes of most right now, but I think it’s only a matter of time until the National media puts him there.
19) Buffalo Bills-Noah Spence, EDGE Western Kentucky- Noah Spence is the “flavor of the day,” after a phenomenal showing at the Senior Bowl. He flies off the edge and has a very good move set for a 3-4 edge rusher.
20) New York Jets- Jaylon Smith, OLB/ILB Notre Dame- If ‘Zeke is off the board, I think the Jets become the most difficult team to decipher in this draft. They could look to grab an edge rusher like Emmanuel Ogbah, Heisman trophy winner Derrick Henry, or maybe a quarterback to sit behind Ryan Fitzpatrick.
However, I think the most likely option, assuming he’s on the board, is Jaylon Smith. Demario Davis didn’t have a great season, and David Harris isn’t getting any younger. So why not get the third best player in the draft at the 20th overall pick?
21) Washington Redskins- Kenny Clark, NT UCLA- I know Terrance Knighton has said he wants to resign with the Redskins, but I would let him walk. The depth at defensive tackle in this draft is too great to ignore, and they can easily find a space eater to replace him (like Kenny Clark).
22) Houston Texans- Derrick Henry, RB Alabama- If Arian Foster doesn’t return, then the Texans are in desperate need of a number one running back. Assuming Henry’s 40 time in Indianapolis is solid, his power and vision make him worthy of a first round selection.
23) Minnesota Vikings- Landon Turner, OG North Carolina- Turner isn’t a great athlete on tape, but he’s a smart player and shows great strength at the point of attack. For a team that runs the ball a lot, he seems like a good fit.
24) Cincinnati Bengals- A’Shawn Robinson, NT Alabama- Robinson could go anywhere from 12-24, in my opinion. In this draft, the rise of Alexander and Peterson force him to fall a bit. I’ll bet Bengals fans won’t be complaining.
25) Pittsburgh Steelers- Austin Johnson, DT/NT Penn State- The Steelers are never going to take a first round cornerback. Therefore, even though I think they should trade up for one, we’ll move past that.
One of the Steelers more pressing needs is someone in the middle of their 3-4 defense. Steve McLendon was below average last season, and is an impending free agent.
Austin Johnson’s a great athlete for a nose tackle with very good pass-rushing ability. I think his versatility will help strengthen the Steelers front seven.
26) Philadelphia Eagles via Seattle Seahawks- Corey Coleman, WR Baylor- New Head Coach Doug Pederson is almost surely going to bring the west coast offense to Philadelphia, which means route running technicians are a necessity. Coleman’s biggest weapons are his quickness out of cuts and his ability with the ball in his hands. Both are key in a west coast system.
27) Green Bay Packers- Andrew Billings, NT Baylor- I have Billings slightly higher than Austin Johnson on my own personal board (for now), but Billings seems more limited in terms of his potential. I get the sense he’s strictly a space eater where as Johnson has star potential.
Having said that, the Packers need a run stuffer in the middle of their defense. That is Andrew Billings in a nutshell.
28) Kansas City Chiefs- Taylor Decker, OT Ohio State- I’m not a huge fan of Taylor Decker, but he’s a solid option as a right tackle. The Chiefs are desperate for some stability at that position.
29) New England Patriots- (Forefeit)
30) Arizona Cardinals- Emmanuel Ogbah, EDGE Oklahoma State- The Cardinals still lack a dominant edge rusher that can get to the quarterback at will. Ogbah has to become more consistent against the run, but he can have an immediate impact in Arizona on third down plays.
31) Dallas Cowboys via Carolina Panthers- Christian Hackenburg, QB Penn State- Having picked up extra assets, the Cowboys have the luxury of moving back into the first round for a quarterback of the future.
Many are going to argue that they should just take a quarterback at four, but if you’re going to roll the dice, why not try to roll a natural seven?
Once upon a time Christian Hackenburg was a lock to be the number one overall pick of this class. He still has the size and arm strength of an NFL quarterback; Penn State’s system just didn’t fit him well. If he gets the opportunity to sit and learn behind Tony Romo, maybe he becomes the star we all thought he would be two years ago.
32) Denver Broncos- Darian Thompson, FS Boise State- This is definitely a luxury pick, but when you’re the defending Super Bowl champions, you can afford to make such a pick.
Thompson is a ball hawk in every sense of the word. The only weakness on the Broncos defense was Darian Stewart, who didn’t even play that poorly. Imagine what someone with 19 career collegiate interceptions could do on a defense where he can afford to constantly take risks.
TRADES
1) Atlanta Falcons trade the #17, #50 and a 2017 2nd round pick to the Dallas Cowboys for the #4 pick.
2) Detroit Lions trade the #16, #46 and the #139 to the San Francisco 49ers for the #7 pick.
3) Seattle Seahawks trade the #23, #55 and a 2017 4th rounder to the Philadelphia Eagles for the #13.
4) Dallas Cowboys trade the #34 and a 2017 4th rounder to the Carolina Panthers for the #31.
2015 NFL Draft Grades: AFC
One of the best sports weekends ever has come and went, and with it, the NFL Draft has been completed. The NFL Draft has become a spectacle in recent years, and while some fans may not know every player their favorite team selected, every fan has the same question after the draft ends. “How did my team do?” Well, here are my 2015 NFL Draft Grades for the AFC teams.
AFC EAST
New York Jets (A-)
Picks: DE Leonard Williams (6th), WR Devin Smith (37th), OLB Lorenzo Mauldin (82nd), QB Bryce Petty (103rd), OG Jarvis Harrison (152nd), NT Deon Simon (223rd)- The Jets hit a home run with their first pick in the draft when they selected Leonard Williams. Any time you get the best player in the draft outside of the top five, you basically can snooze for the next six rounds. While I would’ve rather seen the Jets take Jaelen Strong at the 37, they needed a guy that could stretch the field, and Devin Smith is that. Mauldin and Petty were good value picks (I had Brett Hundley over Petty), and you can’t forget that the Jets turned a fifth and seventh round pick in a horrifically weak draft class into Brandon Marshall and Zac Stacy. This was a great first draft for Mike Maccagnan.
New England Patriots (B-)
Picks: DT Malcom Brown (32nd), SS Jordan Richards (64th), DL Geneo Grissom (97th), DE Trey Flowers (101st), OG Tre Jackson (111th), OG/C Shaq Mason (131st), LS Joe Cardona (166th), LB Matthew Wells (178th), TE A.J Derby (202nd), CB Darryl Roberts (247th), LB Xzavier Dickson (253rd)- This draft was a tale of the good, the bad, and the ugly. The good was Malcom Brown. Belichick stole someone who many, including myself, was a top 20 player in this draft. Brown will be a force in the middle of the Pats defensive line. The bad were the Patriots later round picks. Now in New England’s defense, there was not a lot of back end talent in this draft. However, any time you take a long snapper, you’ve got some explaining to do. Many felt that Tre Jackson and Shaq Mason were good value, but I never felt either team would be a key contributor at the next level. Then there were the Patriots day two selections, aka the ugly. Jordan Richards and Geneo Grissom were extreme reach picks, and both will probably be special teams players. Overall, Malcom Brown and Trey Flowers keep this draft afloat, but it was average at best.
Buffalo Bills (F)
Picks: CB Ronald Darby (50th), OG John Miller (81st), RB Karlos Williams (155th), LB Tony Steward (188th), TE Nick O’Leary (194th), WR Dezmin Lewis (234th)- The Bills easily had the worst draft in the AFC. Ronald Darby is a good player, and he will be a solid addition to the Bills secondary. Outside of that, the Bills did not address a need, nor did they take anyone that was a good value pick. Not a good first draft for Rex Ryan and company. However, there’s no reason to panic in Buffalo. Rex is great at maximizing talent, and his teams are typically not built through the draft anyway.
Miami Dolphins (A-)
Picks: WR DeVante Parker (14th), DT/NT Jordan Phillips (52nd), OL Jamil Douglas (114th), CB Bobby McCain (145th), RB Jay Ajayi (149th), S Cedric Thompson (150th), CB/WR Tony Lippett (156th)- The Dolphins had a great draft. They got a wide receiver with true number one potential in Parker. They nabbed one of my favorite players in the in Jordan Phillips, who will bolster their defensive line even further. Phillips will help gap the run and free up Ndamukong Suh and Cameron Wake. Jay Ajayi in the fourth round was incredible value. He will help take pressure off Lamar Miller, and, in my opinion, replace him one day. The final piece was Tony Lippett, who is a terrific football player. He may not be great at one particular thing, but he will contribute from day one.
AFC NORTH
Baltimore Ravens (A-)
Picks: WR Breshad Perriman (26th), TE Maxx Williams (55th), NT Carl Davis (90th), OLB Za’Darius Smith (122nd), RB Buck Allen (125th), CB Tray Walker (136th), TE Nick Boyle (171st), OL Robert Myers (176th), WR Darren Waller (204th)- Ozzie Newsome addressed offense early in the draft, a rarity in the Ozzie Newsome regime. Perriman has a lot of upside, but he’s raw. Just like the Jets earlier, I think Jaelen Strong should’ve been the pick. However, just like Devin Smith, I had Perriman with a top 40 grade, so I don’t mind the selection. Maxx Williams makes a lot of sense as well. While I would’ve rather seen the Ravens go with an impact defensive player, Williams can help the Ravens offense from day one. Of course, in classic Ozzie Newsome fashion, he got his impact defensive player in round three. Carl Davis was an absolute steal. Buck Allen was an underrated pick as well. He will be an impact player on third down. Overall, Ozzie Newsome got a lot of weapons for Joe Flacco in this draft, and helped sure up the middle of the Ravens defense.
Cincinnati Bengals (A-)
Picks: OT Cedric Ogbuehi (21st), OT/OG Jake Fisher (53rd), TE Tyler Kroft (85th), LB Paul Dawson (99th), CB/S Josh Shaw (120th), DE Marcus Hardison (153rd), TE C.J Uzomah (157th), FS Derron Smith (197th), WR Mario Alford (238th)- The Bengals had a great draft, because they preemptively addressed their needs for next year. Ogbuehi and Fisher are great insurance for Andrew Whitworth and Andre Smith, both of whom are expiring contracts and neither of whom appear to be high on the Bengals priority list. Ogbuehi can sit the year and fully recover from his injury. Fisher can move to guard for the time being and replace Clint Boling. Tyler Kroft is a good blocking tight end, and while he may have been a reach, the Bengals needed a blocking tight end after losing Jermaine Gresham. Paul Dawson can play anywhere on the Bengals linebacking core, and Derron Smith or Josh Shaw is bound to be productive enough to replace Reggie Nelson. This was a great draft for Cincinnati.
Pittsburgh Steelers (C+)
Picks: OLB Bud Dupree (22nd), CB Senquez Golson (56th), WR Sammie Coates (87th), CB Doran Grant (121st), TE Jesse James (160th), DT Leterrius Walton (199th), DE Anthony Chickillo (212th), FS Gerod Holliman (239th)- This is a polarizing draft for me. On the one hand, they nabbed Bud Dupree about ten picks later than he should’ve gone. On the other hand, every single other pick was either a reach or a risk. Golson is undersized, and there were plenty of other corners I would’ve rather have seen them selected. Sammie Coates has a bad case of the drops and I’m not sure it’ll be corrected during his NFL career. Last but certainly not least, Doran Grant wasn’t worth drafting. The Steelers got good value in Dupree and Gerod Holliman, but other than that the draft was below average.
Cleveland Browns (B)
Picks: NT Danny Shelton (12th), C/OG Cameron Erving (19th), OLB Nate Orchard (51st), RB Duke Johnson (77th), DE/DT Xavier Cooper (96th), S Ibraheim Campbell (115th), WR Vince Mayle (123rd), CB Charles Gaines (189th), TE Malcolm Johnson (195th), TE Randall Telfer (198th), ILB Hayes Pullard (219th), CB Ifo Ekpre-Olomu (241st)- The Browns drafted a ton of players that I really like, yet I’m not a huge fan of this draft. Shelton is a big body to put in the middle of an improving defense, but I would’ve rather have seen them take the versatility of Eddie Goldman or Jordan Phillips. Cameron Erving is best suited at center, but unless Alex Mack opts out of his contract after this season, Erving will be playing guard for the Browns, and I’m not a huge fan of him there. Nate Orchard was better served as a 4-3 defensive end, Duke Johnson was unnecessary because of Terrance West and Isaiah Crowell, and Xavier Cooper will have to convert to a 3-4 defensive end. Having said all of that, I can’t get on the Browns too much, because they took a lot of talent in this draft, and addressed needs in the process (minus wide receiver).
AFC South
Tennessee Titans (B)
Picks: QB Marcus Mariota (2nd), WR Dorial Green-Beckham (40th), OL Jeremiah Poutasi (66th), DE/DT Angelo Blackson (100th), FB Jalston Fowler (108th), RB David Cobb (138th), LB Delontrez Mount (177th), C Andy Galilk (208th), WR Tre McBride (245th)- The Titans made the difficult, yet correct decision in taking Marcus Mariota. I believe he can be a franchise quarterback, and Ken Whisenhunt should be able to work with him to get the best out of him. DGB is a great risk/reward pick because he can learn to grow on a team that is still a few years away. Also, I fully expect David Cobb to compete for the majority of touches in the Titans backfield as early as next season. Outside of those three, there wasn’t much value. Yet, the Titans did what they had to do.
Jacksonville Jaguars (A-)
Picks: DE Dante Fowler (3rd), RB T.J Yeldon (36th), OG A.J Cann (67th), S James Sample (104th), WR Rashad Greene (139th), DT Michael Bennett (180th), WR Neal Sterling (220th), TE Ben Koyack (229th)- The Jags draft would’ve been the best of all the 32 teams if it weren’t for unnecessarily reaching on T.J Yeldon, who I full on expect to be a waste of a pick. Fowler, Cann, Sample, Greene and Bennett can all contribute from day one, and Greene and Bennett were absolute steals. The Jags are on the rise.
Houston Texans (C)
Picks: CB Kevin Johnson (16th), ILB Benardrick McKinney (43rd), WR Jaelen Strong (70th), WR Keith Mumphery (175th), LB Reshard Cliett (211th), DT Christian Covington (216th), RB Kenny Hilliard (235th)- The Texans draft didn’t start off great. I felt Kevin Johnson was a major reach, even though they needed a corner. Benardrick McKinney is just very overrated, and I’ve made my opinions on him well known. However, their draft took a turn when they grabbed Jaelen Strong in round three. I think Strong might just be their number one receiver by the end of this year. Unfortunately, there were no day three value picks at all. Overall, the draft was sub par, despite addressing needs. Despite that, draft Strong late in your fantasy football leagues this year, especially in keeper leagues.
Indianapolis Colts (C-)
Picks: Phillip Dorsett (29th), CB D’Joun Smith (65th), DE Henry Anderson (95th), S Clayton Geathers (109th), NT David Parry (151st), RB Josh Robinson (205th), LB Amarlo Herrera (207th), OL Denzell Goode (255th)- I was baffled when the Colts selected Phillip Dorsett with their first pick. Dorsett is a good player, but he won’t play much his first year and wide receiver wasn’t a need. The first pick needed to be an impact defensive player. I like Smith and Anderson in the second and third rounds. Both are needs on defense, and both have a lot of upside. However, there was no late round value picks and they missed on their first selection.
AFC West
Denver Broncos (C-)
Picks: DE Shane Ray (23rd), OG Ty Sambrailo (59th), TE Jeff Heuerman (92nd), C Max Garcia (133rd), CB Lorenzo Doss (164th), DT Darius Kilgo (203rd), QB Trevor Siemian (250th), CB Taurean Nixon (251st), S Josh Furman (252nd): Shane Ray was a good value pick if you talked to most, however I had him as a second round grade. I like the fit because he can learn from Demarcus Ware and Von Miller, but I still say Ray shouldn’t have been a first round pick. Now, Sambrailo was a good selection because he adds versatility to the Broncos offensive line. Other than that though, this was a very weak draft. There’s no value in the picks in the later rounds, and just not enough contributors to their team for the upcoming season.
Oakland Raiders (B)
Picks: WR Amari Cooper (4th) DE/DT Mario Edwards Jr. (35th) TE Clive Walford (68th) OG Jon Feliciano (128th) LB Ben Heeney (140th) LB Neiron Ball (161st) LB Max Valles (179th) OL Anthony Morris (218th) WR Andre Debose (221st) CB Dexter McDonald (242nd): Mike and I said throughout the whole draft process that scouts would make their money in the second, third and fourth round. The Raiders had a very solid draft in the first four rounds. I’ll move past the Amari Cooper selection because it’s self-explanatory. Mario Edwards isn’t a 4-3 fit as a defensive end, so he’ll probably move inside as a defensive tackle. I’m not opposed to that, but I felt there were a number of better players on the board for the Raiders to take. Clive Walford will provide a good safety blanket for Derek Carr on third down, assuming Walford can keep his head on straight. Lastly, Feliciano has good upside and could become a starting guard. It wasn’t a particularly “sexy,” draft, but the Raiders drafted players of need and a true number one wide receiver.
Kansas City Chiefs (B+)
Picks: CB Marcus Peters (18th), C Mitch Morse (49th), WR Chris Conley (76th), CB Steven “Mighty Mouse” Nelson (98th), ILB Ramik Wilson (118th), LB D.J Alexander (172nd), TE James O’Shaughnessy (173rd), DT Rakeem Nunez-Roches (217th), WR Da’Ron Brown (233rd): I was surprised the Chiefs didn’t address offensive tackle in this draft, but other than that this was another solid draft from Andy Reid and company. Peters has a ton of upside, and Reid has done well with guys with character issues in the past. Morse and Conley both elevated their stocks during the NFL Combine, and both have very good upside themselves. I loved the selections of Nelson and Wilson. Nelson should develop into a very solid nickel corner and Ramik Wilson could become their second ILB in the Chiefs 3-4 set. This was a really good draft for Kansas City.
San Diego Chargers (B-)
Picks: RB Melvin Gordon (15th), ILB Denzel Perryman (48th), CB Craig Mager (83rd), OLB Kyle Emanuel (153rd), DE/DT Darius Philon (192nd): The Chargers went into this draft with the intention of getting a number one running back, and they did that with Melvin Gordon. Even though I think it was a little too high for Gordon, after Gurley went tenth, can you really blame San Diego for being cautious and trading up? Perryman was a solid choice because his biggest asset is stopping the run, and the Chargers needed help in the middle of their defense. The Chargers draft will hinge upon Craig Mager. He’s raw, but his upside is immense. If they get a productive corner out of Mager, and Perryman pans out, this could prove to be a very good draft. For now, it’s an average one with potential.
Fan Operated NFL Mock Draft
Welcome to the Fan Operated NFL Mock Draft. We wanted to give our viewers a chance to make selections for their favorite teams, or for any team they were interested in selecting for. We felt this was a cool and unique draft idea to let you all give some input on what your teams should be taking.
What we decided to do was evaluate the selections that you made. We based our opinions on our grades and judgment of the players in this draft, as well as the draft needs that each individual team has.
Now we did disagree with some of the selections, but that doesn’t necessarily mean that your pick is bad. You may see something that we don’t, and down the road, you may have been right. All it means is that at this point in time, we don’t agree with the pick.
Round One
1) Tampa Bay Buccaneers- Jameis Winston, QB Florida State (Kevin Adler)
(Jordan)- Well this was kind of obvious.
(Mike)- Hopefully Tampa Bay feels the same way as we do come draft day.
2) Tennessee Titans- Marcus Mariota, QB Oregon (Anthony Zanfini)
(Mike)- The Titans are definitely going to look to trade here, in my opinion. Plus, they appear to be set on Zach Mettenberger. However, if Anthony was not a Mettenberger fan, then this pick makes perfect sense.
(Jordan)- I agree. Personally I don’t like the scheme fit here for Mariota, but if the Titans were to change their mind on Mettenberger, then a great offensive mind like Ken Whisenhunt should be able to make something out of Mariota’s talent.
3) Jacksonville Jaguars- Dante Fowler Jr., DE Florida (Nick DePinho)
(Jordan)- I like this pick, even with Leonard Williams on the board. The Jaguars got good production from Sen’Derrick Marks and just signed Jared Odrick. They should go edge rusher, and Fowler is the best scheme fit.
(Mike)- I agree on the Williams part, but this probably made more sense to be Vic Beasley. Gus Bradley would love having Beasley’s pass rushing ability in the Leo linebacker role on his defense. I have Beasley ahead of Fowler, so that’s where I would have gone.
(Jordan)- Do you object to Fowler going here all together?
(Mike)- No, Fowler is the most NFL ready among the pass rushers in the draft. He’s also a natural 4-3 defensive end. I just think Beasley has more upside, and would work well in the Jaguars defense.
4) Oakland Raiders- Leonard Williams, DT Southern California (Justin Katz)
(Mike)- Thank goodness the best prospect is finally off the board. This isn’t worth analysis.
(Jordan)- Word, Cotton.
5) Washington Redskins- Vic Beasley, OLB Clemson (Danny Katz)
(Jordan)- The Redskins get my top pass rusher in the draft here to play opposite Ryan Kerrigan. I think they’d be okay with that.
(Mike)- Well I thought Beasley should’ve gone third, so I’m sure they’re going to be more than satisfied.
6) New York Jets- Randy Gregory, OLB Nebraska (Nick Lovera)
(Mike)- Look, the Jets need an edge rusher, and many people like Gregory. However, his combine just furthered everything I’ve seen on tape. He’s too slight to really be an impact player at the next level, and I just wouldn’t have taken him here.
(Jordan)- Well my dislike of Gregory has been more than documented in my mock drafts. After the report of his failed drug test at the combine, I’d be surprised if he went this high. However, these picks were made before that happened. Therefore, if Nick is a fan of Gregory, then he would technically be a good scheme fit.
7) Chicago Bears- Kevin White, WR West Virginia (Joey Zocco)
(Jordan)- Kevin White is a beast, and technically speaking the Bears are in need of a wide receiver opposite Alshon Jeffery. If I were the Bears, however, I’m just not sure I can look at the gaping hole in the middle of my front seven and not take a nose tackle. I believe there are at least four nose tackles that are immediate starters in the NFL, and all are round one picks.
(Mike)- True, but sometimes you can’t deny talent, and Kevin White is one of the two most talented players on the board. This isn’t a matter of right and wrong, this is a matter of best available player.
(Jordan)- The middle of that defense is just so dreadful though. There are times where you can take the best available player, and then there are times where the need is too great.
(Mike)- They did just add Mason Foster to sure up their linebacking core.
(Jordan)- That doesn’t answer their need for a defensive tackle.
(Mike)- Yes, but it can allow them to go for a best available player. Foster is a run stopping, solid tackling, middle linebacker. Kevin White is a fine choice here because of that.
(Jordan)- I’d still take a nose tackle because of how deep the wide receiver class is.
8) Atlanta Falcons- Danny Shelton, NT Washington (JP Lalumia)
(Mike)- Paul Soliai was just recently signed, so I can’t see the Falcons going for a nose tackle. I would’ve gone edge rusher here.
(Jordan)- I agree. I know for a fact that JP is not a fan of Soliai, which is why he made this selection. Despite this, I would have gone with an edge rusher, particularly Bud Dupree; I think he’d be a perfect scheme fit.
9) New York Giants- Brandon Scherff, OG Iowa (Tim Schulze)
(Jordan)- I can’t complain when the Giants take a glaring need, even if I believe in Owamagbe Odighizuwa that much.
(Mike)- Scherff makes a ton of sense, but I would be really tempted to take Amari Cooper here. If they lined up a receiving core of Odell Beckham Jr., Victor Cruz and Amari Cooper, I’m not sure there’s a defense that could contain that besides the Legion of Boom.
10) St. Louis Rams- Amari Cooper, WR Alabama (Justin Katz)
(Mike)- Amari Cooper may run a sub 4.4 40 yard dash, but the Rams team may run to the podium even faster than that to make this selection.
(Jordan)- Nick Foles would benefit from the Rams getting anyone that is a number one wide receiver in this draft. The fact that they pick Amari Cooper is an added bonus.
11) Minnesota Vikings- DeVante Parker, WR Louisville (Doug Kowalski)
(Jordan)- I really hope this happens on draft day because of the Louisville connection between him and Teddy Bridgewater. The Vikings traded for Mike Wallace, so they may not go receiver in round one on draft day. Despite this, I think this is a fine selection.
(Mike)- I think this pick is easy. Bridgewater needs more reliable targets and Mike Wallace only gives the Vikings one dependable receiver. Parker has a history with Bridgewater, which makes me believe their chemistry will translate to the NFL.
12) Cleveland Browns- Shane Ray, OLB Missouri (Ryan Kuck)
(Mike)- Shane Ray is not only overrated, but he’s not a need. The Browns have Paul Kruger and Barkevious Mingo off the edge. This should’ve been a nose tackle to plug gaps against the run (my pick: Jordan Phillips). Even if the Browns wanted to go edge rusher, there are plenty of better options than Shane Ray.
(Jordan)- Ray’s pro day showed exactly why we don’t like him. His hips are slow and he’s not a twitch player. I would’ve gone Jordan Phillips as well.
13) New Orleans Saints- Alvin “Bud” Dupree, OLB Kentucky (Scott Anderson)
(Jordan)- Bud Dupree is one of my favorite players in the draft because of his athleticism and length. He’s a perfect fit in Rob Ryan’s defense. I love this selection.
(Mike)- At first, I wasn’t a huge fan of Dupree. However, after the combine and his pro day, I decided to give him a second look. Dupree is athletic and shows a bevy of pass rushing moves. Putting him next to Junior Galette is a smart pick.
14) Miami Dolphins- Trae Waynes, CB Michigan State (Rob Ricci)
(Mike)- The Dolphins have needed a cornerback opposite Brent Grimes for a while. Waynes is particularly strong in man coverage, which is good considering teams will try to avoid Grimes every Sunday.
(Jordan)- I think they could’ve used a number one wide receiver, but they just traded for Kenny Stills and they drafted Jarvis Landry last year. I can’t complain with them snagging Waynes, even if I don’t believe in Stills at all.
15) San Francisco 49ers- Eric Kendricks, ILB UCLA (Rob Ricci)
(Jordan)- The 49ers have no one playing next to NaVorro Bowman. The end.
(Mike)- I disagree. This is a little high for Kendricks. This seems more like a panic selection considering they could’ve nabbed Stephone Anthony or Paul Dawson in round two. There were plenty of other players on the board at need positions that are higher on my board than Kendricks.
(Jordan)- Kendricks is near the top of my big board, so I have no issue with him going here. I don’t feel it’s a reach and it is arguably their biggest need.
(Mike)- They did just sign Lance Briggs.
(Jordan)- And I’m in about as good of shape as him.
(Mike)- Regardless, I would’ve waited on an inside linebacker because of that.
(Jordan)- Agree to disagree.
16) Houston Texans- Jaelen Strong, WR Arizona State (Austin Greene)
(Mike)- Since we didn’t do trades in this mock, the Texans are in the worst spot in the draft. This is a best available selection. I’m not a fan of Cecil Shorts, so despite the fact they signed him to replace Andre Johnson, they could use a true number two receiver next to Nuk Hopkins.
(Jordan)- I agree with the Texans being in a bad spot because of Trae Waynes not being on the board. I think cornerback is their top need because of how inconsistent Jonathan Joseph was last year. I would’ve gone Marcus Peters, but I admit that Peters here is a reach.
17) San Diego Chargers- Malcom Brown, NT Texas (Chris Chach)
(Jordan)- The Chargers desperately need a nose tackle, and even though I think Eddie Goldman and Jordan Phillips are better, Brown is a perfectly fine selection.
(Mike)- San Diego also needs a pass rusher badly. Having said that, I would have had them taking a nose tackle here as well.
18) Kansas City Chiefs- TJ Clemmings, OT Pittsburgh (House Pick)
(Mike)- Eric Fisher needs to move to right tackle because of how inconsistent he is at left tackle. That makes the Chiefs top priority in the draft a tackle.
(Jordan)- This is why the Chiefs take Clemmings. He’s the best tackle in the draft.
19) Cleveland Browns- Eddie Goldman, NT Florida State (JP Lalumia)
(Jordan)- The Browns should’ve gone nose tackle at the 12th overall, but getting Goldman at the 19 is a steal.
(Mike)- This is a “well duh,” selection. The Browns have to go nose tackle in the first round, assuming they keep both their picks on draft day. While I wish they went nose tackle first so they could consider a wide out here, this is a no brainer now.
20) Philadelphia Eagles- Landon Collins, S Alabama (Tricia Pozzi)
(Mike)- Marcus Peters probably made more sense here because Collins is an in the box safety and the Eagles struggle in coverage. Having said that, the Eagles are just terrible in the secondary in general, so Collins is still a good pick.
(Jordan)- I’m kind of glad Trish left Peters on the board, to be honest. First of all, the Eagles need tacklers, and Collins is a hard-hitting presence in the box. Second, the Eagles start Earl Wolff at strong safety, so there’s that. Lastly, I’m not so sure I want to put Peters and his character issues in Philly, where Chip Kelly is under a ton of pressure to win now.
21) Cincinnati Bengals- Marcus Peters, CB Washington (Nick Prevete)
(Jordan)- The Bengals don’t need a cornerback! They have Leon Hall, Dre Kirkpatrick, Darqueze Dennard and Adam “Pacman” Jones. This makes no sense.
(Mike)- Didn’t the Bengals draft a corner in the first round last year, and in 2012? Chalk me up for confused on this one.
22) Pittsburgh Steelers- Kevin Johnson, CB Wake Forest (Tim Schulze)
(Mike)- This pick makes sense, but don’t expect it to happen on draft day. The last time the Steelers drafted a cornerback in round one they selected Chad Scott in 1997.
(Jordan)- Doesn’t this year seem like a good year to buck that trend though, considering there’s an empty space currently playing opposite Cortez Allen?
(Mike)- In theory, but streaks exist for a reason. I doubt that one of these corners is the one in 17-1.
(Jordan)- Regardless, I like the selection.
23) Detroit Lions- Jordan Phillips, NT Oklahoma (Nick Prevete)
(Jordan)- This just baffles me. You can’t put a zero technique next to Haloti Ngata in a 4-3… who also serves the role of a zero technique. This pick has Preston Smith written all over it.
(Mike)- Smith can bulk up to be a five technique next to Ngata, or he can just stay at his playing weight and play defensive end opposite Ziggy Ansah. I concur.
24) Arizona Cardinals- Todd Gurley, RB Georgia (Danny Katz)
(Mike)- I like Todd Gurley the player, but I don’t like the fit. With Antonio Cromartie going back to New York, a corner is a big need here for the Cardinals. Byron Jones would’ve made more sense.
(Jordan)- Mike, you know the old saying, “when you have two quarterbacks, you have no quarterbacks?” Well, when you have five running backs that can’t stay healthy, you have no running backs. This of course is the ultimate sense of irony here because Gurley is coming off ACL surgery. However, if Gurley was the top running back in Danny’s mind, then this is fine with me.
25) Carolina Panthers- Phillip Dorsett, WR Miami (Michael Desjardins)
(Jordan)- Not only did the Panthers just take a receiver in the first round last year, but Dorsett is just not a good fit. The Panthers need a left tackle in the worst way. This had to be a tackle.
(Mike)- I have six wide receivers currently on the board that are better, in my mind, than Phillip Dorsett. I have five offensive tackles on my board that are higher than Phillip Dorsett. Needless to say, I disagree with the selection.
(Extra from Mike)- An out of the box pick here would’ve been Shaq Thompson. I’m not sure how he fell out of round one, but his coverage ability would make the Panthers linebacking core arguably the best in the league in coverage.
26) Baltimore Ravens- Dorial Green-Beckham, WR Oklahoma (Steve Reynolds)
(Mike)- Ozzie Newsome typically doesn’t take offensive players in the first round. While I really like the pick because of DGB’s undeniable talent, I would expect them to address cornerback or defensive line with this pick.
(Jordan)- The Ravens need a number two wide receiver and a red zone threat. That is DGB in a nutshell. His size makes him a difficult guard, and John Harbaugh should have no trouble taming his character issues. I like this pick.
27) Dallas Cowboys- Melvin Gordon, RB Wisconsin (Kevin Khederian)
(Jordan)- Gordon ran behind a great offensive line at Wisconsin, so I’m sure he’ll be used to not being hit until he’s at least three yards past the line of scrimmage. I think this is exactly what the Cowboys will do on draft day, regardless of whether Todd Gurley is on the board or not.
(Mike)- I think this is a “luxury pick.” The Cowboys need defense badly and are neglecting it to help what is already a good offense.
(Jordan)- They have to replace Demarco Murray in this draft though.
(Mike)- They can do that later on. Edge rushers are top heavy this year, where as running back is the deepest position in the draft. Owamagbe Odighizuwa would’ve been a better pick to play opposite Demarcus Lawrence.
(Jordan)- That’s not fair. You know I’m never going to argue with any 4-3 teams taking my man Digi.
28) Denver Broncos- Ereck Flowers, OT Miami (Chris Emery)
(Jordan)- I despise Ereck Flowers, so you’re going to have to take this one.
(Mike)- Chris Clark needs to be replaced, so I like the idea to take a right tackle.
(Jordan)- Let me stop you right there. Please don’t tell me you like Ereck Flowers.
(Mike)- Actually, I don’t. I would’ve gone La’El Collins or Andrus Peat here. Having said that, the position target is 100 percent accurate.
29) Indianapolis Colts- Cameron Erving, OG/C Florida State (Anthony Scaperrotta)
(Mike)- Cameron Erving looks like a really solid center, and the Colts do interior offensive lineman.
(Jordan)- But…
(Mike)- Their defense is so average. The Colts have to go defense in round one.
(Jordan)- They particularly need a corner to replace Greg Toler.
(Mike)- How does he still start? I’ll say this though. If they choose to not go defense for some reason, then addressing their offensive line with a player that is as versatile as Erving does make sense.
30) Green Bay Packers- Maxx Williams, TE Minnesota (Anthony Scaperrotta)
(Mike)- This is a hard pick to argue against. They start Andrew Quarless.
(Jordan)- This seems like a match made in heaven. Williams is a do-it-all tight end and would serve as a good safety valve for Aaron Rodgers in the passing game.
31) New Orleans Saints- La’El Collins, OT/OG LSU (Scott Anderson)
(Jordan)- The Saints still need more defense, but they are getting a starting NFL guard here. No objection from me.
(Mike)- Agreed. I like the idea of Collins transitioning to guard at the next level, and because the Saints traded Ben Grubbs, this seems like a great selection.
32) New England Patriots- Arik Armstead, DE/DT Oregon (Joe Romano)
(Mike)- This could be the best selection of this mock draft. Not only does Bill Belichick get a positional need here, but he also gets a top 15 talent at the 32nd overall selection.
(Jordan)- Doesn’t this seem like a Belichick kind of selection too? He gets the most versatile defensive lineman in the draft at a bargain price. Classic Patriots.
That does it for our fan operated mock draft. We want to thank everyone who participated in this. This was a really cool idea and we’re both extremely pleased in the amount of people that were interested in this. Even if we disagreed with your selections, we still appreciate everyone that helped out in making this possible.
- ← Previous
- 1
- 2
- 3
- Next →